Law Critisisms Of General Defences

Discuss the criticisms that swallow been made of any two general defence forces and consider what proposals acquit been made for reform of the law.

The general defences have evolved over the years mainly through judicial decisions, with which round have received criticism. The defence of insanity has received several(prenominal) criticisms; the first is that rules are not based on checkup examination exam definitions and the terms used do not relate to medical conditions. Also the rules were created by judges in 1843 and despite gigantic developments in the understanding, diagnosis and treating of psychiatric illnesses the MNaughty rules reside unchanged. In 1953, the royal commission on capital penalisation described these rules as obsolete and misleading and the requirements for disease of the reason as outdated and inaccurate In the cases of Sullivan, Burgess and Hennessey it appears that this defence is too wide covering epilepsy, sleep walking and diabetes, which approximately people would not regard as mental illnesses. other problem is that it is common for there to be conflicting clever evidence at the trial and medically unqualified jurors have to make their decision having heard complex arguments.




However the pen criminal code produced by the law commission in 1989 recommends a new defence leading to a finding of fact of not guilty on evidence of mental sickness. This would arise where the accused was suffering from a range of tough mental illnesses or abnormalities, which would be defined in outline with medical knowledge. Now that the definition of diminished responsibilities has been updated in the coroners and justice act 2009, to bring it more in line with medical definitions reform of the rules on insanity would appear to be hitherto more urgent.
The second Criticism is on the defence of Intoxication. Rebecca Huxley-Binns argues in her book on criminal law that the defence is a mass of inconsistency, lacks any logic and is rooted firmly in policy The defence exist because one of the main functions...If you deficiency to get a full essay, order it on our website: Ordercustompaper.com



If you want to get a full essay, wisit our page: write my paper